A chicken marsala with no wine, gluten free, and migraine safe - that can’t possibly be good, right? I’m here to tell you that it is possible and it’s also quite delicious.
In all honesty, I probably should have named this “Chicken in a Mushroom Cream Sauce”, but it just doesn’t have the same feeling that comes from “Chicken Marsala”. Do you guys have the same memory of Chicken Marsala that I do as one of the ultimate family dinner staples? It’s the kind of dinner your mom serves on a night that everyone sits down at the dinner table and no one complains about what’s on the plate. It was truly one of my favorite meals growing up.
About Marsala Wine & MSG
The traditional Chicken Marsala recipe requires Marsala wine, a fortified wine with a rich savory flavor. Unfortunately wine, especially a wine of this type, can be a huge migraine trigger for many. It can also upset vestibular symptoms.
Contrary to popular belief, alcohol does not completely cook out of a dish. In fact, according to the USDA, in a dish that’s cooked this long it would only burn off about 40%. And if you're sensitive to sulfites, reducing alcohol just concentrates them in a smaller surface area as they do not burn off like alcohol does.
Another factor to consider is whether you have a high sensitivity to MSG. Mushrooms contain free glutamates, so a few people find they are sensitive to them in the same way they would from added MSG. While mushrooms are allowed on Heal Your Headache and MANY can eat them with no issue, it is something to watch for, especially if you eat them often.
Mushrooms & Glutamate
White or cremini mushrooms are the lowest on the spectrum when compared to shiitake or enokitake, which are higher in glutamate. To give you some perspective, the Glutamate Association(apparently this is a thing) estimates there are 180mg in a 100 gram serving (about 4 ounces).
In parmesan cheese, there are 1,680mg in the same amount. Other items on the high end include fish sauce, soy sauce, aged cheeses, and walnuts. This is one of the reasons they should be eliminated on a migraine diet along with their higher tyramine content.
As I said on instagram this week, one of the big reasons I started this site was so people could live their lives as normal as possible. A large factor in feeling good is being able to enjoy the things you love with family and friends. A migraine diet doesn’t have to mean that you have to separate your life (or meals) from others. I hope this dinner encourages you to sit down and enjoy a meal with your family this week. I promise even the pickiest eaters will hardly notice a difference.
Does It Taste the Same?
While Marsala wine does add complexity to the dish, going alcohol free doesn't mean this dish lacks flavor. Garlic combined with heavy cream is always delicious, but adding the vinegar allows you achieve a similar acidity that you would get with wine. Thyme leaves and a bit of mustard powder heighten the flavor. I promise you will not be disappointed!
Tips for Cooking
- A light dusting of flour provides a crispy, brown exterior to the chicken breast, but this can also be achieved through white rice flour or arrowroot powder for those who are gluten free.
- Wipe your mushrooms with a damp cloth to clean them rather than running them under cool water. This will allow them to not become water-logged and get a nice brown caramelization when you cook them.
- Also don't crowd your pan when cooking the mushrooms, as they release moisture, they will steam instead of brown if you put too many in the pan. You may need to work in batches.
Other Alcohol-Free Recipes:
Steamed Clams in Herbed Butter Broth
Wine-Free Short Ribs
Pear Mojito Mocktail
Chicken Marsala (with no wine!)
Ingredients
- 4 thin cut chicken breasts (or 2 large ones sliced in half to about ½" thick)
- 3 tbsp ghee or olive oil and butter * I like to use ghee instead of butter here since it can reach a higher smoke point
- ½ cup all purpose flour * Use white rice or arrowroot flour (for gluten free)
- 1 shallot, peeled and chopped
- 2 garlic cloves, peeled and chopped
- 8-10 oz cremini mushrooms, sliced
- 1.5 cups chicken or vegetable broth * See my instant pot recipe for a quick and easy way to make it
- ¼ cup heavy cream
- 1 tbsp white vinegar
- ½ tsp ground mustard powder (or 1 tsp of dijon)
- 1 tsp dried thyme leaves
- 1.5 tbsp fresh parsley, chopped
Instructions
- Lightly salt and pepper your chicken breasts, then dip them into your flour of choice. Cover both sides with flour, shaking off the excess. Save 1 tbsp of the flour for later.
- In a large pan (emphasis on large!) over medium heat, add 1 tbsp of olive oil and 1 tbsp of butter or 2 tbsp of ghee. When shimmering, add flour coated chicken and fry until golden brown on both sides, about 3-4 minutes per side. Transfer to a plate and cover with foil.
- In the same skillet with the drippings from the chicken, add 1 more tbsp of butter or ghee and melt. Add mushrooms for 3-4 minutes until browned on both sides The major tip here is to not crowd your mushrooms or they will steam. Give them some space in a single layer and they will get nicely browned.
- Add your shallots and garlic to the mushrooms, scraping up any bits from the bottom. Mix in the 1tbsp of flour. Pour in the chicken broth & vinegar and simmer over medium heat for about 5-7 minutes, until reduced by half and thickened.
- Add the heavy cream, mustard, and thyme. Return the chicken to the sauce mixture and simmer another 2-3 minutes to thicken. Top with parsley and serve!
- I like to serve this with cauliflower rice or pureed cauliflower, and green beans.
This recipe is amazing! I’ve made it several times - slightly different depending what I have on hand (i.e. sub heavy cream with coconut milk and white vinegar with balsamic), but it’s always a home run.
Can I use regular milk instead of heavy cream?
I would not use it for this recipe or else it won't be very thick. Sometimes regular milk will also curdle with acid or high heat.
The recipe was great and easy to make. My wife and children loved it. I am going to add this to our dinner rotation
My family and I absolutely LOVE this recipe! It has amazing flavor and is made from ingredients I typically have in the house. Its become a family favorite! Thank you for sharing this recipe!
Thanks, Christel!
This recipe was absolutely yummy. I used red wine vinegar instead of white. Will definitely add to my list of favorites.
Love this recipe so much. We make almost weekly!
I made this sort of....however I used Thighs, did not flour and cook, I made the sauce in a skillet, making a light rue, and adding the ingredients I used, lactose free milk in the sauce....then I put the thighs in a pyrex dish and poured the sauce over the chicken.....Baked in a 375 oven for 1 hour 30 minutes.....OH MY how flavorful and tender...served with black-eyed peas and mashed garlic cauliflower....MY MY that vinegar and mustard was the trick in the sauce....Thank you for the idea....
Sue, I'm thrilled you enjoyed with your edits!! 🙂
Very good!
Made this tonight and it was delicious. My husband loved it too. Thank you Alicia for another great recipe.
Flavorful and delicious. We'll definitely be making it again.
Made this last night, it was delicious!! My husband and 13 year old son both said “this is really good” without being prompted, which coming from them is an enormous compliment! I am more of a dump n go crock pot kind of gal so I was a little intimidated at first but it was actually very easy to make. Thank you for this wonderful recipe, we will be having it often.
I've recently been diagnosed with vestibular migraines and have been switching my diet. We tried this Chicken Marsala tonight - so good! I can't wait for left-overs tomorrow night. The kids ate it too!
So glad you loved it, Sarah! The kids are always the true test haha.
I loved this chicken. The vinegar and mustard gave it a nice kick. I added a bit more of each. I left out the cream because I also follow the WW plan. It was delicious without it!
Thank you, Karen! I'm glad to hear it was still enjoyable without the cream. I need to try that too!